The fog of war eleven lessons from the life of robert s. In this book we use cuttingedge tools from information and control theories to examine canonical and idiosyncratic failure modes of realtime cognitive systems facing fog of war and frictional constraints. The only problem with this neat formula is that he neither uses fog of war nor gives fog significant. Uncertainty and unpredictabilitywhat many call the fog of warcombine with danger, physical stress, and human fallibility to produce what clausewitz called friction, which. You may copy it, give it away or reuse it under the terms of the project gutenberg license included with this ebook or online at. Prepared under the auspices of the center of international studies, princeton university. Militaries employ command and control c2 systems and doctrine to partially alleviate the fog of war. Despite the frequent invocations of his name in recent years, especially. The defeat of the enemy closer definition of the military objectivecontinued.
The fog of war is a reality in all military conflict. What made clausewitzs work on war so successful was that he wrote about war by focusing on its general aspects, or more simply, on the spirit of war as he saw it. Clausewitzs fog and friction and the military transformation. The 197684 howardparet version is the standard translation today. A thesis submitted for the degree of phd at the university of. Consider the more modern versions and other relevant books shown below. Mcnamara, the former secretary of defense under the kennedy and johnson administrations. Essay structure introduction synopsis a central problem. Here the fog prevents the enemy from being discovered in time, a battery from.
By comparing this theoretical version of war with reality, clausewitz aims to identify how and why these two types of war di. As of 10 jul 1827, clausewitz regarded the first six books merely as a rather formless mass that must be thoroughly reworked once more. Especially in recent years, the concept has become popular among both scholars and military organizations. Mcnamara by nick grothaus the fog of war is a film about the life and times of robert s. War is fundamentally an interactive social process. Graham translation of clausewitz s vom kriege 1832 published in london in 1873. Clausewitzs categories of war and the supersession of. The continuing irrelevance of clausewitz small wars journal. He argues that clausewitz is the father of conventional war, where sun tzu is the father of unconventional war. Such metrics assume large forceonforce battles in a clausewitzian. His combination of experience and analytical rigor has allowed him to speak with a timeless voice throughout the ages. The translation of clausewitz s on war is the 1943 version done by german literary scholar o. Scale of the military objective and of the effort to be made closer definition of the military objective.
It has been translated into english several times as on war. Nebel des krieges is the uncertainty in situational awareness. The revived popularity of his great treatise, on war, has generated healthy debates within the us military over the utility of such clausewitzian concepts as centers of gravity, culminat ing points, and fog and friction. The infinite variability of war in the real world and the search for structure. For a period of 175 years, clausewitzs theory on the fog and friction of war has been applicable. War, however, is not the action of a living force upon a lifeless mass total nonresistance would be no war at all but always the collision of two living forces, the ultimate aim of waging war, as formulated here, must be taken as applying to both sides. War has an enduring nature that demonstrates four continuities. The relevance of clausewitzs fog and friction in a digital. Edge challenges military history for leaders clausewitz. Clausewitzs conception of war is strikingly unique. Clausewitz s fog and friction and the military transformation fiction. Pdf clausewitz vom kriege download full pdf book download. A painting of the the battle of moscow, 7th september 1812, from 1822 by louisfrancois lejeune.
Through night and blood to light, and no work yet written conveys to the thinker a clearer conception of all that the red streak in their flag stands for than this deep and philosophical analysis of war by clausewitz. He did speak of fog as a metaphor for wars ambiguities. Current us strategic guidance is advancing the point of view that since the character of war has changed to focus on irregular wars then the. His combination of experience and analytical rigor has allowed him to speak with a. His work and ideas have significantly influenced the strategic theory and his statements and beliefs are among the most frequently cited, and also among the most controversial.
S friction referring to physical impediments to military action, fog to the commanders lack of clear information. In his classic strategic treatise, on war 1832, clausewitz emphasizes the uncertainty under which all generals and statesmen labour known as the fog of war and the tendency for any plan, no matter how simple, to go awry known as friction. Dealing with fog of war in a real time strategy game environment pdf. The result is in some cases, particularly in military circles, clausewitz taught as a catechism. Precision and certainty are unattainable goals, but modern military doctrine suggests a trade off of precision and certainty for speed and agility. On clausewitz is a thorough survey of all of clausewitzs most important insights, drawn not only from on war but also from his voluminous writings on military history and international politics. The revision would aim to bring out the two kinds of war more clearly. In this way, war no longer drew on narrow and specific contexts, but rather became understood, as an enduring phenomenon, in. Clausewitz, alan beyerchen nonilnearity, and the unpredictability of war ialthough our intellect always longs for clarity and certainty, our nature often finds uncertainty fascinating. Clausewitz called it a zweikampf literally a twostruggle and suggested the image of a pair of wrestlers locked in a hold. Wallach as most would suspect when studying clausewitz is looking to establish relations between the military and politics. In conflict research, this has become the most widely quoted definition of war. On clausewitz is a thorough survey of all of clausewitz s most important insights, drawn not only from on war but also from his voluminous writings on military history and international politics. In this book we use cuttingedge tools from information and control theories to examine canonical and idiosyncratic failure modes of realtime cognitive systems facing fogofwar and frictional constraints.
While jominis art of war traces its lineage to the french enlightenment, clausewitzs on war reveals the inluence of a german intel lectual movement that built upon but signiicantly departed from the core. Although dating to the 19th century, many of the lessons remain poignant and relevant to this day theory of conflict, and phenomena such as the fog of war, remain important parts of military theory. Human impulses and human frailties shape wars natureit is not deterministic. Based on a detailed reading of clausewitz book on war, this paper proposes that clausewitz reflections on strategy unfold along two parallel arguments. Periodically, to be sure, there have been geniuses who. Clausewitz theory of war, background and trinity youtube. Clausewitzs categories of war and the supersession of absolute war 1 christopher bassford vers. For the moment, i leave aside comment on some of his best points, many of which are fairly banal war is politics by other means, the fog of war, frictionand commonplace, that is true but not uniquely so. For the moment, i leave aside comment on some of his best points, many of which are fairly banalwar is politics by other means, the fog of war, frictionand commonplace, that is. In this way, war no longer drew on narrow and specific contexts, but rather became understood, as an enduring phenomenon, in general terms. It argues that clausewitz abandoned the idea of absolute war which appears almost exclusively in the first half of book viii of on war, that ideal war is a distinctly new departure in book 1, and that clausewitz did relatively little further work to the manuscript of vom. What made clausewitz s work on war so successful was that he wrote about war by focusing on its general aspects, or more simply, on the spirit of war as he saw it. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading clausewitz.
Clausewitz curses chaos and the fog of war as barriers to victory. Clausewitz s on war and sun tzus art of war in one volume. Clausewitz, a napoleonic era prussian officer, authored a number of fundamental concepts5 later designated in popular jargon as the fog of war, center of gravity and the selftitled absolute war which is a darker concept that warfare. Far from being the bloodyminded apostle of total war portrayed. The nature of war is enduring yet the character of war changes over time.
1072 257 1441 613 1482 1219 1000 208 611 993 143 1227 1025 927 209 1138 639 1530 472 1074 599 53 480 625 67 652 1001 1057 1454 336 890 993 1317 203 687 640 1281 485 1440